Eneloop Self Discharge study

SilverFox

Flashaholic
Joined
Jan 19, 2003
Messages
12,449
Location
Bellingham WA
Sanyo started the ball rolling with low self discharge NiMh cells with the introduction of their Eneloop cells. I, along with several others, have been testing these cells for roughly a year now and they seem to be holding up to the manufacturers claims.

Sanyo claims 2000 mAh for their AA cells, and we are finding that to be very close. Sanyo claims that they can be used right off the shelf, and that also seems to be true. Sanyo also claims a cycle life of 1000 charge/discharge cycles. I would love to be in a position to check this out, but, for now at least, we will just have to believe them on this. The final claim is that they will still have 85% of their initial capacity after 1 year of room temperature storage.

This is what I found:

Here is the initial test data on these cells

EneloopAA2000atVariousRates.gif


You can see that they are very strong performers. I even included the data from the 30 day self discharge for comparison.

I then took a pair of cells and stored them on a shelf in my house. Data was taken at 0, 30, 90, and 180 days. Here is what that data looks like.

EneloopSelfDischargeStudy.gif


You can see that the biggest drop in capacity comes in the first 30 days. After that, things settle down. Looking at the numbers we have about 93% of the initial Amp Hours after 30 days and about 91% of the initial Watt Hours for the same time period. At 90 days we have about 88% of the initial Amp Hours and about 85% of the initial Watt Hours. At 180 days we have about 86% of the initial Amp Hours and about 82% of the initial Watt Hours.

I can easily see how these cells could still have 85% of their initial capacity at the end of a year. I am only going to project out to the year mark because I am going to be using my cells. Someone else can do the 1 year testing…

I did not note the voltage of the cells at 30 and 90 days, but at 180 days each cell was at 1.313 open circuit resting volts.

Update: 3/17/08

I just finished testing a set of 9 cells that I normally use in my Mag85. I set them aside a year ago and just finished testing them. Under a 1 amp load, they came in at 1578 mAh. Initially they came in at 1871 mAh, so you can see that they did not live up to their 85% remaining charge after a year of storage.

However, 84.34% is pretty close...

Several people have reported their self discharge test results and they seem to be quite low for normal NiMh cells. A lot of published information has NiMh cells in the 0.5-1% per day self discharge range. I was seeing around 0.7% per day with several brands of cells, based on short term tests of around 30 days. This seems to still be a little high for healthy cells. The problem 2500 mAh cells will completely self discharge in around 10 days so keep in mind that I do not consider those cells "healthy."

Here is a graph of NiMh self discharge rates comparing original cell chemistry to the Eneloop cell chemistry.

NiMhSelfDischarge.gif


The 0.7% per day line is pretty close to what I, and others, have reported, but it seems to be pessimistic at 90 days and beyond.

The question of the suitability of the Eneloop cells for use in a remote control or other low drain device has often come up. We know that the self discharge rate is faster early on, then it tapers off. I was concerned that there would be little difference between the normal chemistry rate and the Eneloop chemistry rate, initially, and there might be little advantage in using the Eneloop cells in applications like this. This study indicates that even at the 30 day self discharge rate, the Eneloop chemistry is a lot better.

Ray (Codeman) ran some discharge tests on some Eneloop cells that had been stored for 12 months. The have a manufacturing date indicating that they are 19 months old. You can find his results in this post. Thanks Ray.

Unfortunately we don't know how much charge they initially had. Sanyo Europe stated that they were putting around a 70% charge into the cells, and we are assuming that this practice is universal, and has been in place since the cells were first introduced.

MorePower sent me some RayOVac Hybrid cells to check out. Thanks.

I will be following the same testing proceedure I used for the Eneloop cells.

Here are the initial test results.

HybridAA2100atVariousRates.gif


Here are the results from the self discharge study on the Hybrid cells. I will add data as it becomes available. I am using the same storage and testing conditions as I did with the Eneloop cells. The test results are from a 0.50 Amp test.

HybridSelfDischargeStudy.gif


The Hybrid cells are better than normal NiMh cells, but not quite as good as the Sanyo cells.

Cannesahs picked up some GP ReCyko AA cells for me. Thanks Jyrki.

The capacity of the battery was not labeled, so I guessed at 2050 mAh. EDIT: They are labeled as 2100 mAh and 2050 mAh minimum. ENDEDIT These are very strong cells. I was surprised that they almost held up over 1.0 volts at 10 amps. I think the voltage of the Eneloop cells is a little higher, but these are very strong cells.

Here is the initial data.

GPReCyko2050AAatVariousRates.gif


It will be interesting to see what their self discharge rate is. Testing in progress...

Here is some test data from the Eneloop AAA cells.

EneloopAAA800atVariousRates.gif


And here is the self discharge study on these cells.

EneloopAAASelfDischargeStudy.gif


There doesn't seem to be much self discharge between 30 and 90 days. The odd numbers are from slight differences in the cells. I used 4 cells for these tests and rotated them in pairs for the various test periods.

Update 5/23/2009

In March of 2006 I ordered and set aside some AAA Eneloop cells. I just got around to needing them and decided to see what they had left in them as far as capacity goes. Over the last three years they have been stored at room temperature.

They ended up with about 550 mAh left. This is about 74% of their original capacity...

Not too bad... :)

Tom
 
Last edited:

Anders

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 16, 2005
Messages
637
Location
Stockholm.Sweden
Hello Silverfox.

Thx a lot for your time and effort to do this and all the other tests for us here at CPF.

I just ordered some more Eneloop cells:)

Useful information as always, thanks again:awman:

Anders
 

Codeman

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 26, 2004
Messages
2,690
Thanks for all the hard work Tom! I think it's time to start swapping out cells in my hotwire lights.
 

wasBlinded

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 14, 2004
Messages
1,222
Location
Oklahoma
I have 4 Ray-O-Vac Hybrid cells and 4 Eneloop cels that I did a "Refresh-Analyze" on the MAHA c-9000. I plan to let them sit for 30 days (end of the month) and do a discharge test on them. It will be interesting to see if the Eneloops match your results, and how the Hybrids compare over that period.
 

Robstorch

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
129
Great work! But some of us consider it fun using our chargers more often!
 

Robstorch

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
129
Forgot to ask, not sure if you know or not how the eneloops handle fast charging with the Energizer 15 minute charger?
 

coppertrail

Enlightened
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
920
Yes, this is really great information. Thanks for taking the time to complete this study :)
 

Brighteyez

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 5, 2005
Messages
3,963
Location
San Jose, CA
I think Tom mentioned in another thread that they work fine with the 15 minute chargers, but those chargers do take a toll on the overall life of the batteries.

Robstorch said:
Forgot to ask, not sure if you know or not how the eneloops handle fast charging with the Energizer 15 minute charger?
 

Bearcat

Enlightened
Joined
Aug 13, 2006
Messages
415
Location
Germantown, TN USA
I sure would like to see a heads-up comparision between the Eneloops and Rayovac Hybrids. Hopefully, they will be close to the same, since I loaded up with Hybrids for $3.87 per package of 4-AAs and I used up all 10 of my $5.00 off coupons.
 

Phaserburn

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 30, 2003
Messages
4,755
Location
Connecticut, USA
Fantastic work and great news! I am more than happy with this rate of charge retention. Knowing I can count on 86% of a full charge after 6 months is terrific; it takes all of the mental overhead out when trying to remember (or worse, write down) when specific cells were last charged. If you just assume you have around 1.7Ah or so to play with regardless of when they were charged, you'll be in the ball park for your calculated runtimes. Not too shabby.
 

jezzyp

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 29, 2005
Messages
326
Location
S Yorks, England
I think that a lot of CPFs will now buy a lot of eneloops - and tell others to buy them.
Its just a shame that Sanyo will never reward Silverfox for massivly upping their sales.
Still at least we appreciate the work done.
 

Bullseye00

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
157
Location
Orlando, Florida USA
It'd be nice to get a comparison of all the major low self-discharge NiMh batteries, but SilverFox is probably tired of super long-term self-discharge testing about now. Maybe if people would donate the the batteries to him, we could persuade him to do another round of testing.
 

etc

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 19, 2004
Messages
5,777
Location
Northern Virginia
Interesting. So they discharge slower, much slower than conventional Ni-MH.

Question: Given the lower 2,000 MaH capacity, does it mean one will get more recharge cycles than the higher capacity 2700 MaH cells?
 

Eugene

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
1,190
etc said:
Interesting. So they discharge slower, much slower than conventional Ni-MH.

Question: Given the lower 2,000 MaH capacity, does it mean one will get more recharge cycles than the higher capacity 2700 MaH cells?


They self-discharge slower to be correct. And yes they should last for more cycles, fewer charge cycles is one of the tradeoff's of the higher mAH batteries.

I've bought a few and have had a set in our digicam for a couple weeks now which is so far better than regular NiMH's which would self trigger the low battery after a couple weeks.
 
Top