Watt to Lumen conversion

[stuartgmilton]

Hey guys,

I found a conversion that said 1 lumen = 0.0003Watts. Surely this is wrong?

You can buy a 3Watt flashlight, which has an output of 65L, so is there anyway to compare the 2 values?

Stuart

[HKJ]

Hey guys,

I found a conversion that said 1 lumen = 0.0003Watts. Surely this is wrong?

You can buy a 3Watt flashlight, which has an output of 65L, so is there anyway to compare the 2 values?

Stuart

That may be correct at some specific color, but:
Lumen is defined according to the eyes sensitivity, i.e. the watt<->lumen conversion is depend on the color of the light. One extreme is UV/IR light, your can have lots of watts in it, but the lumens are 0, because we can not see it.

And with flashlights (and anything else), your can not expect a 100% conversion, a lot of energy is wasted in heat.
Some typical values are:
incan: 5-30 lumen/watt
led: 60-100 lumen/watt

incan will have improved efficiency when really hot, i.e. very white light.
led will best efficiency at low output.

[Marduke]

No, there is no conversion between lumens and watts. The "wattage" of a flashlight gives you absolutely no idea how bright it actually is.

When a manufacturer lists watts, you have no idea if they are stating the LED draw, the battery consumption, the max rating for the LED, or simply pulling a number out of thing air.


Furthermore, it depends on the LED efficiency. A current generation can produce over 100 lumens on 1 watt of power. Dial the time machine back a few years, and a previous generation might only do 40 lumens for 1 watt of power.

[CM]

Lumens is what matters. Watts is marketing.

[stuartgmilton]

Cheers guys,

That will settle an argument!

[HKJ]

Lumens is what matters. Watts is marketing.

Watt may be marketing in flashlight specifications, but there are conversions between watt and lumens.

One conversion is lumen output from bulb with a specific watt input. That depends on lots of factors.

Another one is how many watt a specific light "contains", that is a exact measure, but depends on the color of the light.
See here for a formula http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminosity_function

[TranceAddict]

you're talking about 1 apple equal to how many oranges.

watt is a derived unit consist of work done(energy) over time.

while lumen itself is the basic fundamental unit, not derived from any unit but exist as a standalone unit in nature. you can't break it down further or you will be another Einstein.

[HKJ]

you're talking about 1 apple equal to how many oranges.

watt is a derived unit consist of work done(energy) over time.

while lumen itself is the basic fundamental unit, not derived from any unit but exist as a standalone unit in nature. you can't break it down further or you will be another Einstein.

Not exactly correct.
You have "radiant flux" that is measured in watt, this is light and other radiation without any compensation for the eyes sensitivity.
If your know the spectrum of your "radiant flux", your can convert it to "Luminous flux", that is adjusted to the eyes sensitivity.
The absolute best conversion is with 555nm light, there your have 683 lumen/watt and the worst is anything outside the eyes range, this will have 0 lumen/watt. Anything in between is possible, depending on the spectral contents of the radiation.

[TranceAddict]

we are focusing on the visible electromagnetic spectrum, but no datasheet provides good info regarding within which spectrum it emits radiation and its strenght, while you're trying to include full spectrum of EM, consisting RF and even gamma ray. too complicated to derive power from flux within the range.

[HKJ]

we are focusing on the visible electromagnetic spectrum, but no datasheet provides good info regarding within which spectrum it emits radiation and its strenght, while you're trying to include full spectrum of EM, consisting RF and even gamma ray. too complicated to derive power from flux within the range.

It does not really matter if your include full spectrum or not, anything outside the visible spectrum is bvery easy to convert to lumen (it is 0 lumen).

Getting the spectrum of a led is not that difficult, in fact your can find the spectrum of many lamps on the ledmuseum, see here: http://ledmuseum.candlepower.us/seventee/itpop.htm

Anybody wishing to do the math, can get a rater good estimate of the optical power in watt, from the lumen value.

[Marduke]

HKJ,

I think the OP is talking about the "on the package" wattage rating vs how bright a light is, not really going into the physics behind the energy involved.

ie. Application, not theory

[TranceAddict]

It does not really matter if your include full spectrum or not, anything outside the visible spectrum is bvery easy to convert to lumen (it is 0 lumen).

Getting the spectrum of a led is not that difficult, in fact your can find the spectrum of many lamps on the ledmuseum, see here: http://ledmuseum.candlepower.us/seventee/itpop.htm

Anybody wishing to do the math, can get a rater good estimate of the optical power in watt, from the lumen value.

just find the function of the line and do integration with given limit, or simply use approximation method like power series, not really hard in mathlab, but the problem is, different wavelenght(frequency) has different energy, we can't say given same intensity, energy of 10mhz is same as 10ghz.

now you have one more changing variable with respect to the frequency domain, how you gonna solve it in integration ?

more over you have to take the non-linear efficiency curve as well, as energy is wasted as heat form. another changing variable. unless manufacturer provide info of Vf and If on different brightness setting, if the flashlight uses MCU for infinite brightness level and PWM is deployed .....fainted....

[HKJ]

just find the function of the line and do integration with given limit, or simply use approximation method like power series, not really hard in mathlab, but the problem is, different wavelenght(frequency) has different energy, we can't say given same intensity, energy of 10mhz is same as 10ghz.

I do not now waht your mean here, it is the formula that i linked to in my first entry?

now you have one more changing variable with respect to the frequency domain, how you gonna solve it in integration ?

I am not going to solve it, but splitting the light into discrete frequencies and use some weights for each frequency it not that hard.

more over you have to take the non-linear efficiency curve as well, as energy is wasted as heat form. another changing variable. unless manufacturer provide info of Vf and If on different brightness setting, if the flashlight uses MCU for infinite brightness level and PWM is deployed .....fainted....

Now your are getting to calculating the efficiency of the led. Typical values of If and Vf and other led parameters can very often be found in the data sheet (Cree has curves for many different values).


But how much work your want do do, depends on what your want to know:

Input watt for output lumen: Just use the lumen/watt specification.
watt in light: your need spectrum and lumen.

[MrGman]

you cannot determine the lumens output of any LED source based on watts of power consumed as has been said before.

If you know exactly how many lumens you actually have, I believe there is a formula that tells you how many watts of power that is equivalent to but not how much is being drawn from the source to make it which is quite another thing.

You can't say because I have 3 watts of energy at the source, I therefore have X amount of lumens going out. There is absolutely no formula and no one has ever shown a way to do this.

Example: a 100 watt light bulb may give off 1100 lumens. That 1100 lumens of actual light output is not 100 watts of power, it may actually be the equivalent of 10 to 15, maybe not. A lot is lost as heat in the conversion. there is no direct mathematical formula to say 100 watts in is X lumens out. Lumens simply have to be measured by a system specifically designed and calibrated to do it. Not open to debate.

[TranceAddict]

it can't be fourier transformed easily in my opinion, it is not a continuous discreet signal anyway.

[HKJ]

you cannot determine the lumens output of any LED source based on watts of power consumed as has been said before.

Why not? Most led has a lumen/watt specification, for a Cree Q5 is is minimum 107 lumen/watt, then your have to do a derating, depending on temperature and current (All these numbers are in the datasheet).

But if your want total efficiency, from battery to torch lumens, your have a problem, because your are missing some specifications (DC converter, optical system).

You can't say because I have use 3 watts of energy at from the source, I therefore have X amount of lumens going out. There is absolutely no formula and no one has ever shown a way to do this.

(Note: the red words are the original text, I assume that he means the green words)

This again depends on what specification your have

Example: a 100 watt light bulb may give off 1100 lumens. That 1100 lumens of actual light output is not 100 watts of power, it may actually be the equivalent of 10 to 15, maybe not. A lot is lost as heat in the conversion. there is no direct mathematical formula to say 100 watts in is X lumens out. Lumens simply have to be measured by a system specifically designed and calibrated to do it. Not open to debate.

It is is a standard 120 volt 100 watt light bulb it will give about 1700 lumen, and it will be about 2.5 watt radiation energy.
Many bulb types has specifications, that allows estimation of lumens and radiation energy.

[Marduke]

HKJ, you're missing the point. If a flashlight says it's "X watts", there is no way for you to convert that to lumens.

You don't know where they are measuring (if they are measuring at all), you don't know the specs of the LED and driver specifically, and you don't know the thermodynamic properties of the specific light in question. Presumably you don't have the flashlight in hand, so you cannot even take these measurements if you wanted to. You would also have to fully understand the optic system used to derate those effects also.

And assuming you COULD do all of the above, you would still end up with an approximation of an estimation, which may or may not be even close to the real value, as can be measured in an integrating sphere.

[swordfish2]

HKJ, you're missing the point. If a flashlight says it's "X watts", there is no way for you to convert that to lumens.

Ok, how can we convert lumens to candles ? seriously i don know this.

[Marduke]

Ok, how can we convert lumens to candles ? seriously i don know this.

You can't. They measure two different things.

[HKJ]

HKJ, you're missing the point. If a flashlight says it's "X watts", there is no way for you to convert that to lumens.

You don't know where they are measuring (if they are measuring at all), you don't know the specs of the LED and driver specifically, and you don't know the thermodynamic properties of the specific light in question. Presumably you don't have the flashlight in hand, so you cannot even take these measurements if you wanted to. You would also have to fully understand the optic system used to derate those effects also.

And assuming you COULD do all of the above, you would still end up with an approximation of an estimation, which may or may not be even close to the real value, as can be measured in an integrating sphere.

That is correct and I have not said otherwise.

And your last point about estimations are very valid, an estimation might not be close to the real value, but can show bogus specifications.

[swordfish2]

You can't. They measure two different things.

ok, but we cannot even compare these? something like
100 lumens is greater than 100 candles? anything like that?

[HKJ]

Ok, how can we convert lumens to candles ? seriously i don know this.

candelas is lm/st, i.e. "lumens" in a specific direction, to convert between candelas and lumens your need a radiation diagram, showing the radiation in every direction.

[Marduke]

ok, but we cannot even compare these? something like
100 lumens is greater than 100 candles? anything like that?

No, you cannot. Lumens is a measure of total output, where candles/lux is a measure of throw.

[TranceAddict]

The lumen (symbol: lm) is the SI unit of luminous flux, a measure of the perceived power of light. Luminous flux differs from radiant flux, the measure of the total power of light emitted, in that luminous flux is adjusted to reflect the varying sensitivity of the human eye to different wavelengths of light. The lumen is defined in relation to the candela by
1 lm = 1 cd·sr = 1 lx·m2reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumen_(unit)

sorry my bad, lumen is a derived unit from candela, candela itself is base fundamental unit.

[mdocod]

I think the answer that the OP was after was something more along the lines of how to make a comparison when there are packages hanging on the shelf at target with different "wattage" listed on them.

The important point to take away from this, considering the motivations of the OP, is that, wattage on a package has very little meaning about how good or how bright or how useful a flashlight is going to be.

There are Modern flashlights that use ~2W of electrical energy, that perform as well as flashlights that use 5W from just a couple years ago. And there are still plenty of flashlights out there on the market that are using older emitter technology still... A Modern 1W Cree flashlight can outperform the older 3W Luxeon flashlights. The difference is quite amazing. Not just in total output, but the modern cree does a lot better as far as having a wider color spectrum.

The best way to compare is to look at how the flashlight performs when tested by reviewers who have the means of comparing runtime and output of various flashlights.

Many of the flashlight manufactures that are targeting CPF type audiences as their primary customers, have completely stopped listing watts, as it's often meaningless. Some of them have even stopped advertising lumens, instead, they just list the type of emitter used, and how much current the driver is set to run across the LED. From that we know what "class" of output the flashlight is in. Exact lumen figures are meaningless in actual use. Beam shape and color spectrum are often more important factors when comparing lights that are in the same ballpark of lumens.

Eric

[swordfish2]

mdocod, well said.