I just received my Stinger HL a couple days ago, along with the Bianchi Accumold Elite loop to hold it on my duty belt for use while working security. I've been playing around in the house (after a full 10 hours on the charger as directed in the instructions) and comparing it to my Thrunite Scorpion V2 w/ Turbo Head (my previous duty light, with 2 fresh 123 primaries). There isn't much information on the internet about the Stinger HL so I figured some people might find my initial impressions useful.
- Total lumen output on max seems to be about the same between the two to my eye.
- The Stinger HL has a slightly larger hotspot than the Scorpion V2 w/Turbo Head.
- The Stinger HL is longer than the Scorpion V2, but being carried on the belt it seems to be the perfect size.
- The Stinger HL uses the dimming function that makes movement look strobey (I think it's called PWM). I tried this out by moving my hand in front of the beam and found it distracting enough where I probably won't use the medium or low modes very often, especially if there's a chance of shining it on something that's moving. Since it's a duty light, and it always comes on in high first no matter which switch is used, this isn't a big deal for me.
I don't have a fancy camera to take useful beam shots so I won't try.
I decided to try out the Stinger HL since I was looking at options to move the light from my pocket to my belt, and I recently acquired a TLR-1 HL, which I like. The Scorpion w/Turbo Head was just slightly too large for the left front pocket on some pants. Bianchi makes a nice loop for Streamlights and Surefires. The Surefire lawman was out of my price range so the Stinger HL seemed the best choice. It's nice to have my left front pocket free for use as a pocket, not dedicated to being a flashlight holder.
As far as general purpose lights I think the Scorpion is much better than the Stinger. The different modes on the Scorpion can be accessed without having to turn the light on in high first like one has to do with the Stinger. The Scorpion has a low low, and a programmable steady on mode, while the Stinger's lowest low is still over 100 lumens…way too much for a bedside "walking down the hallway in the middle of the night" light. The PWM also kills any usefulness the medium and low modes would have on the Stinger.
My first quality light was a Streamlight UltraStinger, so I was happy to see Streamlight offering a reasonably priced, made in the USA light with comparable output to what I have already been using that's made in China. I also have a Streamlight TLR1 HL on my duty weapon, and the Stinger HL makes a good companion to that. I'll probably be carrying other lights for off duty/EDC, but for duty Streamlight is making some decent stuff.