For me, for 2017 ...
Best production torch
OR B.O.S.S. Ti 70 in XP-L HI 4000K + red
Best custom torch
Sigma Regulus Proto
Best value torch
Emisar D4 in XP-L HI 5D 4000K
"Coolest" torch
First-Light Tomahawk MC
So, I was pretty impressed by the Emisar series this year, and tried the D4, D1, and D1S. The star of this show is the UI, shared by all of them of course, but the D4 edges the others primarily on account of its more generally useful floodier beam.
In the production arena, I had been clamoring for a BOSS in Ti for some time, and it did not disappoint. Glad to see the lightly stonewashed "raw" finish, and much prefer the warmer rosier tint of this 4000K HI over the very slightly greenie 4500K RD in my Satin Black Aluminum version.
As for customs, I can't really improve on my Regulus handmade in gorgeous AlBr. I posted a mini-review and comparison with the BOSS elsewhere here, but it has the look and feel of a fine tool which has been passed down for generations.
And just for its weird / odd / cool factor, the Tomahawk is the most unusual and unique of the torches I tried over the past twelve months. I can't say that the UI is easy or intuitive to use, but the form factor and features are unmatched.
Since New Years is now only a couple days away, I guess that'll do it for 2017 ... :wave: