Review: Lux-RC Minion R1

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
This is the first review I've done for submission to the review forums, but I'll do my best! Please pardon any formatting errors or erroneous grammar.

Official specifications from the manufacturer

I should start off by giving a little background regarding Lux-RC Labs and its owner. Lux-RC Labs is based out of Russia and run by a single individual named Serge Dolgov. As I'm sure many of you are already aware, Serge handles the electronics of Team Oveready's flashlights (such as the awesome BOSS 35) and is the creator of the venerable 371D light engine. What might be lesser known, however, is that Serge manufacturers his own flashlights unilaterally of Oveready. Prior to the introduction of the Minion R1, Serge's products were limited to the FL33 and a few other exclusive flashlights. I recall visiting Serge's website a few years ago and being blown away by the cost and exclusivity of such lights.

What sets the Minion apart from Serge's previous products is the manner by which they are sold, as well as the availability. The Minion R1 represents - in my opinion - Serge's gambit into the market that characterizes the custom flashlight world today; waves of "drops" in which lights are sold on a first-come, first-serve basis. Serge's flashlights are sold exclusively from the Lux-RC website. Each time, Serge has a set amount of certain LEDs, secondary LEDS, and other options available for purchase.

But enough background information. Let's talk more about the Minion itself! There is a myriad of options with this flashlight. Here's a breakdown of the options:

TIR or Mule. TIR uses the standard Carclo optic. From the TIR alone, you have your choice of narrow clear or narrow frosted. The Mule has no optic and exposes the bare LEDs. The TIR works better if you intend to use the light in a more general-use capacity, good for short to medium-range tasks. The mule has no defined hotspot and is best for close-range tasks.

Sapphire/UCL Glass. This is a new option that Serge introduced in the first 2018 run, I believe. Pretty self-explanatory stuff. Sapphire ranks at a 9 on the Mohs scale of hardness and is the third-hardest mineral in the world. The UCL glass is, well, UCL glass. The Sapphire option adds on about $150 at the time of this review. Normally, it'd be a no-brainer to go with the UCL glass. As Henry of HDS Systems himself has said, sapphire offers little to no benefit over UCL. With the Minion, however, the glass is entirely exposed similar to some watch faces. Because the glass is not recessed, as in many other flashlights, sapphire DOES have an advantage over UCL. There have been a few reports of the UCL in Minion's breaking upon impact, although they are few. Whether the upgrade is worth ~$150 is at an owner's discretion.

Red/Amber/Yellow-Green Secondary LED. Red and amber both have their advantages and disadvantages. They are outlined here courtesy of Oveready. The Yellow-Green secondary is a new option to the first 2018 run.

XP-L HI 4000K/XP-L MDC 4200K/219C 4000K/XP-L2 5000K. These are the primary LED options at the time of this review. The brightest is the XP-L2 (2500 lumens at the LED), but I believe that it is exclusive to the Mule version because the LEDs are incompatible with the Carclo optic of the TIR. XPL-HI (1900 lumens at the LED) is the second brightest and is available in both mule and TIR. XPL-MDC (70% of HI's output) is the third brightest and has a smoother beam and transition than the XPL-HI. Nichia 219C has the best color rendition (CRI) of them all, albeit with the least output.

Leather Necklace w/ Holder or "Naked". The Minion has a magnetic tailcap that can connect to a holder for keychain/necklace carry. I highly recommend purchasing the holder; the Minion loses much of its utility "naked". Whether or not the holder is worth the $60 upcharge is debatable, but it's definitely a must.

At the time of this review, Serge is also offering a wrist-mount kit for the Minion R1 that can be purchased for an additional $400. I'm not sure exactly what it entails, but the upcharge is significant. You can also opt to 3D print a wrist-mount with an STL 3D file available on the site.

The options I chose to go with were TIR, XP-L MDC, amber secondary, and UCL. I also purchased the necklace holder. I chose the TIR because I've had mule flashlights before and they simply weren't my cup of tea. If possible, I would've preferred 219c, but unfortunately they were not an option with the TIR in this run. After briefly consulting Serge, I made the decision to go with the MDC for the better beam profile. I only chose amber because my BOSS 35 already has the red secondary and I wanted something different (lol). UCL because I'm a broke student who doesn't want to pay the $150 upcharge.

Shipping from Russia took what seemed like forever. I'm an instant-gratification type of person, so I really suck at these types of waits. I bomboarded Serge for updates constantly, which he must've hated! It should be noted that Serge also ran into some delays with production and had to design some sort of contraption to get things going again. My light shipped out after what I want to say was a little more than a month. Waiting for the light to get from Russia to the US was the worst part - according to the tracking it took almost three weeks! Once tracking updated on USPS and it gave an expected delivery date, I almost ran into another hurdle: signature confirmation. For once though, things went my way. Luckily my family has a pretty good relationship with the mailman and I've been known to chase her down to get a package that needs signature confirmation. This time, she just signed the package for me and updated the tracking with "left with individual". Yay! I almost panicked when I saw that because I was in class and there was no one at home. I ended up thanking her the next day for going to the trouble.

This is what arrived out of the packaging:


oYTRfCF.jpg


Very nice and professional. The box may not be as nice as Muyshondt's or some other customs, but the environment sure appreciates it. The packaging seems similar to Zebralights? Very eco-friendly, I like it.

This is what was inside when I opened the box.

gMpKcc9.jpg


X6fW4es.jpg


Serge includes a very nice bi-fold card with general instructions and some specifications. I think the card is recycled plastic.

Here is everything else that is included (minus the Mini-Griptillian). Leather lanyard, magnetic holder, the light itself.

Wm71JxT.jpg


7HPkcOG.jpg


The above picture is the exact set-up I'm running with this light. I lack the knot-tying skills to use the leather lanyard, so went with a metal necklace I had lying around. The magnet on the end of the light does attract it, but it doesn't impact real-world use. In fact, it makes it much easier to get the Minion into my pocket quickly (the necklace attracts to the tailend of the light) if I need to take it off my neck.

Here is a size comparison to a few of my other lights.

JcppknW.jpg


As is seen, the Minion is truly tiny! I knew it would be small, but lining it up with other "small" lights really puts things into perspective. Keep in mind that the Minion is powered by an 18350 battery, so it's not much bigger than the battery on its own! On the topic of batteries, the type of battery definitely makes a difference with this light. Because of the insane tolerances, using a button top is ill-advised. With some longer button tops, the light doesn't twist far enough to close off the O-ring sufficiently, thus leaving a "gap" as well. I would highly recommend using a flat top, as such. I've had good luck with the Keeppower 750 mAh. The Efest 700 mAh is the perfect fit on mine, though, and allows for the light to turn on when it is fully twisted with zero gap. I will also note that the Keeppower 1200 fits. Battery fitment was an issue on the first run of Minions, but it seems that Serge has improved on the design of this run.

pxSwSyh.jpg


LW0Xb3c.jpg


Here is a picture of the Minion with its clicky-brother, the Oveready BOSS 35. As can be seen, both share the same 371D light engine, albeit with different LEDs.

72mei4M.jpg


On the topic of the 371D, the 371D is simply put the most advanced light engine on the market today. And at $120 a piece it damn well better be. I won't pretend to understand all of the jargon regarding the 371D, but it has zero PWM, allows for a secondary LED, a bounce setting, and wireless optical programming: a combination that no other driver on the market encompasses. The H17f is a close favorite of mine and allows for more flexibility IMHO, but lacks the secondary LED of the 371D and some other features. A new driver that's also catching steam is CWF's Dragon driver. I wouldn't go so far as to call it a "poor-man's 371D", but I do think the 371D is superior overall. Here are a few photos that shows the wireless-optical programming in action.

WGFHS5s.png


Here is the Minion in programming mode. As you can see, the secondary LED takes a much less-bright output to indicate it's ready.

WFBCEvc.jpg


Actually programming the light:

CvWUsuk.jpg


If I were to play Devil's Advocate, I'd say the biggest weakness of the 371D is its perceived longevity. Because it's based off of the Lux-RC website, you won't be able to program the 371D if the website goes down. It will also be outpaced by advances in driver technology, as previous versions were. The biggest advantage of drivers like the H17f and Dragon is that they operate unilaterally of a web-based program. I will say though, what a lot of people fail to realize is that you can actually DOWNLOAD the video file you use to program the 371D. The video file is literally a single pixel blown up and flashed in a sequence, so the file size is absolutely tiny. In other words, you can download programs in advance or upload them to the cloud in the event that you want to program the 371D and you don't have access to the internet or the website is down.

In terms of longevity, the Minion is made to last. The fit and finish are superb, as is the build-quality. An issue with previous runs of the light was that the contact would wear down over time or chew up the battery This has been remedied with a new (brass?) button. I think stainless steel, overall, was the right choice of material. The next best metal would be titanium I think, but that would have been far too cost-prohibitive for production. I considered aluminum, but it simply isn't as strong as the stainless steel. The benefits of aluminum would be better heat conductivity and weight. That being said, I don't think the Minion is too heavy although you definitely feel its presence (which can be reassuring in its own way). I know that Serge has released a few, limited Minions in ceramic which is quite cool. In the event that the light does break, though, Serge has you covered with a life-time guarantee. Of course sending it back is a real hassle...

Le4v6Lo.jpg


BvGigU1.jpg


Going on a little more about durability and overall longevity. The Minion has an IP68 dust/ingression rating. This is one of the highest ratings possible (I think? It might be the second. I *think* IP69 is a thing). I asked Serge and he confirmed that the Minion is fully waterproof to 10 meters. I did submerge the Minion in a glass of water for half-an-hour with zero issues. I will also confess to having worn the Minion in the shower hehe. Despite the issues that can arise from the hotter temps (pressure and steam), I've experienced no issues and could not find any evidence of moisture getting past the o-ring. Serge has also mentioned several times that he uses watch technology to get the UCL on seamlessly. I can't attest to the actual effectiveness, but it sure looks nice and and my watches have never had an issue being submerged.

Here's a few more pictures of my Minion with my Haiku and Emisar D4.

mg1n4jD.jpg


PuvTJyj.jpg


Let's talk some concluding thoughts. I think that in it's totality, the Minion is a home-run for Serge an Lux-RC. It represents some legit innovation, something that has been lacking as of late in the custom world. Even if its another triple, is there another triple this small and bright? The Minion currently holds the record for the most lumens to size ratio. In the flashlight world, lights seem to keep getting bigger and brighter. The Minion is the antithesis if there ever was one. I also think it's pretty impressive that Serge has been able to pump out as many of these Minions as he has. Similar to how Oveready has kept BOSS production up, I think it'll be interesting to see if Serge is able to do the same. In terms of the design choice, I think he made the right choice to go with a niche category. To my knowledge this is the only 18350 "neck light". The only other comparable lights in this category are lights like the Mecharmy Illuminex, which the Minion absolutely tramples. I think Gyorgy Kemene's Omicron is the only real other custom in this category. I have a good mind to pick one of his Omicrons up too, if funds allow! In essence, from both a business perspective and a product perspective, I think that Serge has done an excellent job with the Minion.

This is easily the longest write-up I've ever done on CPF and any flashlight I own at all. Sorry if it got a little long-winded, but I hope it lends some insight. Time will tell how this light holds up and I intend to update the post accordingly. Thanks for reading!
 
Last edited:

sygyzy

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 29, 2003
Messages
749
I am really excited to read your review and at first glance, it looks like you put a lot of effort into it. I have a small request: can you fix the first page of your review so the font is "normal" sized?
 

MikeSalt

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 10, 2007
Messages
1,948
Location
Stoke On Trent, Staffordshire, UK
Thank you very much for taking the time to review this in detail. Facebook groups are great for instant gratification, but if I'm sinking serious money into a light, I like to see proper reviews like this :thumbsup:.
 

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
I am really excited to read your review and at first glance, it looks like you put a lot of effort into it. I have a small request: can you fix the first page of your review so the font is "normal" sized?

Sorry, I typed up the first part on a Google Doc. Fixed it [emoji106]

Thank you very much for taking the time to review this in detail. Facebook groups are great for instant gratification, but if I'm sinking serious money into a light, I like to see proper reviews like this :thumbsup:.

Thanks! I really wish there were more product reviews of customs too.
 

ven

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
22,533
Location
Manchester UK
Great write up and pics the0dore:cool: Thats one sexy little beast! Love it and a big fan for a while now. I do admire Serge's work, a genius for sure. I think given the option, optics would be my choice. I love mules and find them very useful, but with this kind of investment, i wand want a broader use from it. Optics allow for close up and to moderate distance, so that would be my choice also.

Good stuff:twothumbs
 

Eric242

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 18, 2006
Messages
2,931
Location
[-Mad in Germany-]
Great writeup theOdore3524 :thumbsup:

I will also note that the Keeppower 1200 fits. Battery fitment was an issue on the first run of Minions, but it seems that Serge has improved on the design of this run.

pxSwSyh.jpg
We basicaly talked about that in the other thread ;) The 1200mAh Keeppower did NOT fit my Minion. It was stuck so bad, I had to remove it with pliers. It didn´t come out any other way. Thoses Efest are the best fit in my Minion as well, followed by the AWs. Earlier Efests with a more blueish wrapper also didn´t fit well in my light. So I´d say battery fitment is still an issue. Though I think the main issue is that some battery manufacturers make the cells bigger than they should be. On the other hand, if Serge would make the battery compartment slightly bigger to accomodate such cells, there shouldn´t be an issue anymore (they all fit the BOSSes for example).

On the topic of the 371D, the 371D is simply put the most advanced light engine on the market today.
Personaly I think McGizmo´s HIVE is the most advanced with way more options than the 371D. But it´s also not that easy to programm.

Even if its another triple, is there another triple this small and bright? The Minion currently holds the record for the most lumens to size ratio. In the flashlight world, lights seem to keep getting bigger and brighter. The Minion is the antithesis if there ever was one.
Yep, but I think it is worth to mention, that the Minion gets really hot really fast on the highest settings so that those 2500 lumens are available for seconds only before the light steps down. I will re-programm my light so that my highest setting will be avilable for some more time than the max lumens actually is.

Eric
 
Last edited:

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
Great write up and pics the0dore:cool: Thats one sexy little beast! Love it and a big fan for a while now. I do admire Serge's work, a genius for sure. I think given the option, optics would be my choice. I love mules and find them very useful, but with this kind of investment, i wand want a broader use from it. Optics allow for close up and to moderate distance, so that would be my choice also.

Good stuff:twothumbs

Thanks Ven...yeah that's my rational too ;)

Great writeup theOdore3524 :thumbsup:


We basicaly talked about that in the other thread ;) The 1200mAh Keeppower did NOT fit my Minion. It was stuck so bad, I had to remove it with pliers. It didn´t come out any other way. Thoses Efest are the best fit in my Minion as well, followed by the AWs. Earlier Efests with a more blueish wrapper also didn´t fit well in my light. So I´d say battery fitment is still an issue. Though I think the main issue is that some battery manufacturers make the cells bigger than they should be. On the other hand, if Serge would make the battery compartment slightly bigger to accomodate such cells, there shouldn´t be an issue anymore (they all fit the BOSSes for example).


Personaly I think McGizmo´s HIVE is the most advanced with way more options than the 371D. But it´s also not that easy to programm.


Yep, but I think it is worth to mention, that the Minion gets really hot really fast on the highest settings so that those 2500 lumens are available for seconds only before the light steps down. I will re-programm my light so that my highest setting will be avilable for some more time than the max lumens actually is.

Eric

That's a bummer dude. Because these are made on an individual basis, I suspect that there are small nuances in battery fitment between each Minion. Just a tip, but if you remove the magnet holder on the back it becomes much easier to pop the battery out. I wasn't able to get my battery out initially, but once I took off the magnet holder, the battery popped out quite easily.

I don't have any hands-on experience with the HIVE, but I took a look at how to program it and immediately knew I was out of my league haha.

I also agree that the highest setting isn't that practical. It's more of a show-off setting for me than anything!
 

Eric242

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 18, 2006
Messages
2,931
Location
[-Mad in Germany-]
Just a tip, but if you remove the magnet holder on the back it becomes much easier to pop the battery out. I wasn't able to get my battery out initially, but once I took off the magnet holder, the battery popped out quite easily.
I´m not quite sure what you mean by "magnet holder", the lanyard attachment thing ;) ? I didn´t get that becaause I don´t wear anything around my kneck.

Eric
 

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
I´m not quite sure what you mean by "magnet holder", the lanyard attachment thing ;) ? I didn´t get that becaause I don´t wear anything around my kneck.

Eric

You're missing out!! It's so useful. And yeah, the lanyard attachment. Do you just carry yours in a pocket then?
 

Eric242

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 18, 2006
Messages
2,931
Location
[-Mad in Germany-]
You're missing out!! It's so useful. And yeah, the lanyard attachment. Do you just carry yours in a pocket then?
Yes, I just carry it in a pocket..... (and might stonewash the body therefore...... haven´t decided yet). I never wear necklaces, rings, watches and such things.

Eric
 

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
So, I've had the Minion for about a week or so and I've come to some more conclusions. First off, the Minion is probably my first true "EDC" (every day carry) flashlight. I have it around my neck pretty much 24/7 and even when I sleep.

Currently my settings on the light are set to Amber secondary, 0.6%, 3%, and 55%. I will confess to have never had a practical need for the highest setting yet, but there's little doubt that it's impressive. Most of my use with the Minion is on the second and third setting. The light has never heated up on Amber or 0.6%, but I could feel heat after an extended period of time with the 3%.

Let's talk more about actual use. Maybe it's just me, but the Minion really comes in handy when I wake up in the middle of the night and gotta use the toilet. I don't use the locator beacon; I think it's silly and obtrusive. Because I don't use the locator beacon, it might explain why its easier for me to keep it on when I sleep: it's much easier to find. I've switched out the metal chain I was initially using with the leather cord. It took about five minutes to set it up when I actually watched a video online on how to tie the knot lol. The leather cord with the knot is a lot more versatile IMHO. It allows you to adjust how high or low the Minion rests; in general, I like to wear it higher. When I run though, I like to wear it lower. Having the Minion bang against your chest every step is NOT fun.

Here's a picture of how I normally wear it:
kbaqFEN.jpg


I definitely would not wear it over my shirt. It would look ridiculous IMHO and would sort of defeat the purpose of carrying it. I have a neck knife and like to reach under my shirt to deploy it. In such a respect, the way Serge implemented a magnet in the Minion's design is ingenious. I simply reach under my shirt and wallah I have the Minion in my hand. Unlike with the neck knife, I don't even have to look to put the Minion back, the magnet snaps it back.

Some other considerations of importance. While the weight of the Minion is pretty manageable, I wish it was a little less light sometimes. If Serge made a smaller version similar to the Minion with a smaller battery - like 10280 or 10180 - it'd be crazy cool. Granted there are trade-offs, like less output and capacity, but I do find myself wishing that the Minion were a tiny bit less obtrusive at times. Another way I like to use the light is to just turn it on and let it hang outside my shirt. Easy, hands-free illumination. However, this is the one type of use where I can see the advantage of the mule. 120 degrees would disperse the light a lot more effectively in this scenario. That being said, if you plan to use the Minion stand-alone without the lanyard attachment, I think it makes more sense to go with the TIR.

Time will tell how the Minion holds up, but as it stands, the Minion is definitely a keeper/grail in my eyes. I don't foresee myself selling it anytime soon.
 

Dingle1911

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
438
Thanks for the review. The Minion looks like a great light.

I agree that neck carry is the way to go for a light like the Minion.
 

the0dore3524

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
1,323
Location
California (Bay Area)
Thanks for the review. The Minion looks like a great light.

I agree that neck carry is the way to go for a light like the Minion.

You're welcome! It's certainly earned itself a place in my collection of keepers.

Thanks for the review.

Thanks for taking the time to read it ;)

Glad the Minion is working out well for you Theo! Cool mighty light!

Indeed it is! Thanks Dave [emoji109]
 
Top