I don't invest a lot in kids flashlights. They tend to lose or misplace them. My son at age 7 went to a Cub Scout camp out and promptly lost a very nice Gerber. After that I swore off expensive lights till he was older and more responsible. I take two approaches. First, I keep a supply of those HFT freebies. If those get lost or broken, then no big deal. In my ongoing effort to teach him responsibility, I still get on him if he loses one. My second approach is get a BIG light. For example I bought my son a rayovac LED that looks like a classic 6V lantern with a handle. Only this version is LED and uses 4-AA. This light is too big to get lost. Even when he dropped it in a field with tall grass, we still located it. He has managed to keep that one for over three years now.