Surefire Maximus, Minimus AA, Minimus Tactical and Minimus Vision!

[Owen]

Holy crap. It's in the middle, and I couldn't see it when I looked down in the loop. Guess who feels unbelievably stupid now? I'll have to edit that!
Note to self: sleep first, play flashlight after...

I tried the Minimus some at work last night, but it suffered the same problem as when I tried one of my H30w Zebralights after my H60w died-not enough output without killing the battery, and made worse by not having a rechargeable option. Lots of dark areas surrounded by ones with bright ambient light, so it has to be cranked up to get much use from. I'd love to have a Saint version with a 4xAA pack for my hardhat. Not gonna hold my breath for that one, though!

 

[Owen]

-It's dim. Lowest output is significantly lower than my Zebralight SC51Fw's L2 advertised at .16 lumens. My multimeter only reads in multiple of 10mA, so 10mA is what it shows at lowest.
-It's bright. Highest output is probably triple the SC51Fw's H1 advertised at 164 OTF lumens. Pulls about 1A at max output.
-It's everything in between. Runtime for my use will not be an issue. My H30w on medium draws ~50mA from a CR123A, and is more than I need for night hiking. Due to the more concentrated beam, similarly usable output from the Vision draws ~30mA.

Ok, keeping in mind these are handheld with a point and shoot camera without lockable settings, and each of these must be viewed individually-cannot view these side by side and get an accurate representation of brightness between them(white balance set with SC51Fw on high on white door, but the wall is beige, so tint is relative):

Zebralight SC51Fw(or H51Fw-should be the same) L2, rated .16 lumens vs. Minimus Vision's lowest setting:

Zebralight H30w on low, rated <4 lumen vs. Minimus Vision's lowest setting:

Zebralight SC51Fw H1, rated 164 lumens vs. Minimus Vision's highest setting:

Malkoff M60WLF, rated 100 lumens vs. Minimus Vision's highest setting:

So...yeah:thumbsup:

 

[pulstar]

Wow, this thing looks bright! And warm! And with quite a throw! Damn, now i am really thinking about buying minimus vision...

 

[yota4by4]

A week ago I had a similar problem with a Surefire Saint headlamp on a critical all-night SAR mission. Delayed a helicopter several minutes fiddling with it before giving up and scrounging for an older, dimmer, inadequate backup to go along with a hand flashlight. Sent it to Surefire, will see what I get back. Was kind of eyeballing the maximus until this happened, and then read your story. I was able to get the Saint to work the next day, but not about to trust it miles away from support until Surefire takes a look at it.

This is to Jerimoth and/or Bill in AZ:
Has the problem been identified and fixed?

 

[BenChiew]

The latest revision of the Minimus has addressed the body tension issue by replacing the two static tension pins with larger pins that have a small set screw in each pin to allow user adjustment of the tension to compensate for wear/manufacturing tolerances, the artifact issue has been eliminated by modifying the refector housing, excessive light knob tension has been adressed with internal seal changes, and the knob lengthened to improve grip. Additionally, a battery cap lanyard has been added to prevent knob dropping/loss.

Is there a way to identify the latest improved version by just looking at the lamp? or from the box?

 

[Justintoxicated]

Ok, keeping in mind these are handheld with a point and shoot camera without lockable settings, and each of these must be viewed individually-cannot view these side by side and get an accurate representation of brightness between them(white balance set with SC51Fw on high on white door, but the wall is beige, so tint is relative):
.....

So...yeah:thumbsup:

That looks like way more than the 75 lumens it is rated for. Is that the minimus or maximus?

 

[RNDDUDE]

OWEN...thanks for the pics, but I am a bit confused, of the 4 different SF headlights in the thread title, which are you alluding to? You seem to be describing a Maximus (the 500 lumen 18650-based rechargeable) but you say Minimus (C123 or AA versions) in your post. Can you clarify which you were evaluating?

 

[Owen]

 

[Justintoxicated]

Wow so the 70 lumen Minimus (CR123) actually puts out well over 164 lumens of the zebralight. Looks like over 400 lumens in the picture above, maybe more, picture looks more like my S12 vs my H51C

Why on earth would they under-rate the light so much, I don't see how that creates a selling point for surefire.

The Maximus must be insane.

 

[justchillin]

I received a Maximus as a late Xmas gift from my friend a few weeks ago. It looks/feels a little bulky but it was light enough to stay strapped to my head. I charged it up til the indicator was green. Strapped it onto my head and boy is it BRIGHT!!! Compared to my Saint it's BRIGHT. It lights up the room. Anything that's 30 feet away is well lit. It has a clicky feel when adjusting it up and down. The on/off knob turns nice and smooth. Easy one handed operation. I also have the Saint and the Maximus is a big improvement!!! I would prefer to have a CR123 option just in case the built in rechargeable battery runs out.

 

[Jerimoth]

So far I am waiting to hear what Surefire says about the problem I reported earlier. I would be reluctant to rely on it for my primary SAR headlight sticking instead with a Lupine or PT model and several backups.

 

[P_A_S_1]

I have a Minimus which I basically use when I go hiking and overall I'm pretty happy with it. They're a little pricey and I think the runtime on high should be better but I like it. I do wish it had some sort of 'lock out' tail cap designed into it to prevent the light from coming on accidentally. This would have been a nice safety feature and be less of a hassle then removing the battery. Otherwise so far so good. If I was doing it again I'd probably go with the Vision, it seems similar to a M61LLW. To those that have both the Minimus & Minimus Vision if you don't mind posting I would like to see a comparison shot of the beams.

 

[Owen]

I do wish it had some sort of 'lock out' tail cap designed into it to prevent the light from coming on accidentally. This would have been a nice safety feature and be less of a hassle then removing the battery. Otherwise so far so good.

My Vision came on accidentally last week while riding in a hipbelt pocket on my pack in anticipation of being used. Fortunately, it was at the very lowest setting. My solution is keeping it in the Oakley "Soft Vault" case that gets used for my sunglasses. I wear sunglasses right up to sunset, so when it gets dark, they go in the case, and the headlamp comes out. Works out pretty well. I don't think I'll be needing both at the same time!

 

[Bill in AZ]

This is to Jerimoth and/or Bill in AZ:
Has the problem been identified and fixed?

I received a replacement Surefire Saint. Have had a couple of long duration nighttime SAR's and it worked fine. Last Saturday I had another all nighter, quite a bit of it in water in a deep canyon. It was never submersed due to PFD, though very likely splashed a few times. Towards morning it powered itself off occasionally - a bit disconcerting in a deep, dark canyon. Possibly due to low battery, though my previous light simply went dim when battery went low. Played with it a bit before putting in new batteries. If I turned it on fairly low, it would stay on for a while, then randomly cycle off, but if I turned it up all the way it would flash 3 times, then remain on at high setting instead of going dim. I have done some searching to see if this is expected behavior, but haven't found anything yet. Found some references to if it gets hot it may power itself off, though it did not feel hot, and it was a cool night in the low 40's. I had run it on its highest setting all night due to a tricky water rescue.

Does anyone know what the behavior of a Surefire Saint should be? Either overheating or maybe when the battery gets low? I think I would much prefer the light simply go dim rather than power off.

 

[Jerimoth]

This is all very worrisome from a SAR perspective. When you head off with your 24-hour pack you know you might actually be gone for longer than that, and everything- from your insulation to your crampons to your ropes, biners, and pro- all need to bomber. You have to pack light enough that you're not exhausted after a carry-out and you don't become a patient yourself.

Also, if you're being picked up by a regular medical helicopter - e.g. something other than a national guard Blackhawk, and inserted on scene, every ounce counts - you're expected to know your own weight and the weight of your pack so extras of anything are a problem. For now I'm waiting to hear what GoingGear has to say- they told me they are awaiting word from Surefire. For now I'll stick with other lights that I know are bombproof.

 

[Bill in AZ]

I had an older handheld Surefire 9P (I think) with me all night and it *was* submerged for several hours. It also quit by morning, though it did not appear to be wet inside. I got it working again next day by scraping the outer contact of the switch, and running emery cloth over the mating side on the flashlight body.

I sent an email to Surefire asking about the odd behavior of the Saint. Hope to get an answer soon, as SAR season is off to a busy start. What's your bombproof headlamp, and is it waterproof?

 

[Jerimoth]

I have a Petzl Ultra - I'm not sure the exact name of the model, but I'm impressed with the lithium battery and how long it lasts. Seems very rugged and has survived dense rain, and snow but I've never dropped it in the water. It's a bit on the heavy side, so I was optimistic about the Surefire which I think is lighter, and I have always had great success with older Surefires.

I had a bicycle light- Light-in Motion model 200, I think it's name was, that was actually pretty bombproof, and lightweight. It was stolen when I ditched my pack to respond to a heart attack with an O2 tank and AED and had to lighten my load- somebody stole my pack and I lost that light- which actually I think seemed more bomber than the Petzl- and a GPS unit, and a uniform jacket, sleeping bag, and bivi sack, among other things.

I also have a Lupine halogen - not sure of the name but it's not made any more- so I'm saving up for maybe another Lupine model if the Surefire really doesn't work out. As a backup I use the Black Diamond Storm- which so far as survived a number of nights in the snow- not in New hampshire where I work but on vacation in the Andes- in NH we didn't get much snow this winter. So, I'd rank the high output headlights, in terms of being bombproof:
Light in Motion
Petzl Ultra or Lupine
Black Diamond- waterproof but not as beefy as the others.
I also carry a few mini coleman headlights- el cheapo but very light weight- afterall there was a time when the 3 LED Petzl Tikka was all one really needed for most rescues or for alpine climbing.
The need for more throw and flood, now that it's available, isn't overwhelming- In fifteen years I've never ever found someone with a bright light- oddly called in this forum "the SAR light" because in New Hampshire the trees are so dense that for most of us it's always been with air scent dogs or a whistle or a FLIR on a helicopter- but still it's nice to be able to light up an area to see if it'd make a good LZ, or light up an area in front of a litter team to figure out where the trail is, or where there are various obstacles such as downed trees and waterbars. Oddly, I think the most important thing it does is makes it clear that I'm in charge! Sometimes after an exhausting rescue I don't want to have be yelling at people- rescues work much better when people cooperate and aren't overly driven by testosterone. Slow is smooth- smooth is fast, and I'd rather keep it mellow and not have to deal with people who think they're in charge when they're not- we call it the Mr. Rescue syndrome. So I think lumen firepower is actually similar to other ways of asserting authority- a badge, a gun, etc. - it helps assert authority.

The other use of the new breed of LED lights is unrelated to SAR - it's in park law enforcement- coming on a campsite where people are rowdy and drunk and disturbing others- and I'm alone-they can't see me because of the campfire- an insanely bright handheld light to the eyes has a way of sending people scurrying to their tents. I turn up my radio volume and they don't know much but they know I'm not alone.

 

[P_A_S_1]

Was able to check out the Minimus Vision in a sporting goods store today. It was hard to really get a good idea of the brightness and color due to the bright store lighting but overall it was nice. Better then the standard Minimus. They also had the older style Minimus there to compare it with. One things for sure is the original style was definitely a smaller package. While I prefer the feel of the newer model I do wish they kept the size the same. The newer seems large and bulky in comparison. Surefire should strive to make the next generations of the Minimus similar in size to the original, similar in build quality to the current model, better runtime (think HDS), and some how incorporate a 'lock out' battery cap. That and lowering their price point slightly to be more competitive and I think they would have something special. Wishful thinking ?

 

[cland72]

My Minimus Vision shipped today, and I am excited to get it. After reading this thread I'm definitely going to carry my Petzl Tactikka as a backup until I'm comfortable with the SF's reliability (which is why I bought it in the first place).

 

[pjandyho]

If you read the starting page of this thread you will notice that I gave quite a negative feedback on the Minimus Vision. All these have changed over time. In actual use, the beam artifact is not really an issue unless white wall hunting. As for the squeaky rotary switch, Surefire got it sorted out for me so it is now no longer squeaky. I admit that I hadn't used the headlamp much when I first got it, but ever since it came back from SF I have been using it frequently and boy do I love it now.

It has a very nice warmish tint suitable for outdoors usage and the rotating switch dial makes it a breeze to change output levels although sometimes I still get annoyed by the fact that I am always accidentally grabbing onto my hair while rotating the dial. Maybe I really need to get myself a GI haircut to really enjoy this light but it is still bearable. Also, I prefer the SF headband over the ones supplied by Zebralight as it felt more stable and doesn't allow too much wobble on my head. Though I still like my Zebralight headlamps, I find myself going for the Minimus Vision more and more. During a five days field exercise in the Army, I have been using the Minimus Vision every night for cooking and reading during my free time, and since I frequently use it on medium or lower outputs, the single CR123 lasted the five days and more when I continue to use it for some of my personal camping trips. Definitely efficient enough for my usage.