Tonight at Target (Orem, UT) I picked up:
Niteize Drop-in
Dorcy Super 1 watt
Brinkman 3 watt
Niteize Drop-in - Had been excited about this one since it first surfaced on the board after the SHOT show. Religiously been checking walmarts and targets from Twin Falls, Idaho to Phoenix, Arizona since that time. Low and behold...Target had 'em tonight. $9.99. Dropped it in my 3D mag (4C PVC mod w/radio shack 3.6v bulb) and it was kinda like going to a movie with low expectations and still being disappointed. I never thought it was going to blow me away, still i was kinda excited to find it on the shelves. Pure novelty factor...weak, sickly green...blah, blah, blah.
Dorcy Super 1 watt - DOA. Yes....had seen this one at double the price in Sears and Sportsman's Warehouse and was stoked to find it at $19.99. No joy. Have taken it apart twice....Genuine Lumileds star, but I think I got a bad one...shorted direct from (-) to the body, still nothing, so it's not the switch...Head was VERY easy to dissasemble (mod?) switch is glued I think. Haven't decided whether I'll try another or just order a Q3.
Brinkman 3 Watt - The star of the otherwise lackluster show. Also reminded me of the G2...just a little "chubbier?" Glass Lense. Very quiet forward clickie. On the way home I bumped the switch - flashing my eyes - and had a moment of panic on the freeway. VERY Bright. Painfully so. My 6p and Strion "seem" more tolerable. Tight hot-spot with nice throw across my 60' backyard. Reminds me of my Dorcy Metal Gear....just MORE. More brightness...hotspot...spill....also $10 more. Head and switch are very easy to disassemble (mod?) Everything just un-screws, no thread lock and feels like good o-ring seals. Real Lumileds star. Over-all I'm very, very pleased with it. Already micky-moused two 123's in and it's noticeably brighter with a probably much better run time curve? With a shim sleeve and 10 minutes with a dremel........
Cliff's Notes:
Niteize 2-6 cell mag drop-in - "meh...."
Dorcy Super 1 Watt (single 123) - DOA
Brinkman 3 Watt - "winna, winna, winna" Though so much more so for 10 bucks cheaper.