So, I'm an AA person, with AAA being second, because - really - I'm an Eneloop person, haha.
This was what I had in reach.
Top left, clockwise:
Fenix Silvglow, two of those freebie Olight i3e's (I've got a few more around, these were the two most recent ones), Reylight Pineapple Minis (519A), Killzone penlight (519A), two Peak Eigers in high CRI warm (and a head with a different emitter - 5000K 519 with a wide beam in the ultra head), two Convoy AAA's (3000K and 4000K), Maglite 2xAAA Spectrum, Surefire Titan Plus, Maglite Solitaire Spectrum, and one of the Skilhunt E3A's from my PILE of those.
I'll share some thoughts.
Mediocre ones (no AAA light is bad):
Olight i3e: nicely made, fun colors, but horrid CCT. 100% worth the $5 shipping for the freebies. The $13 MSRP is WAY too much, though.
Fenix Silvglow: Sharp edges, okay beam. I like the modes and the color, but this was really underwhelming. For all the praise I've heard of Fenix quality, I have to remember that most people don't own US made lights, because this is clearly Chinese.
Good ones:
Reylight Mini Pineapple: nice beam, great shape, nice feel. It ALWAYS turns on if I carry it, so I no longer do. The smooth body is amazing for pocketing, but the grenade texture feels better in hand.
Maglite Spectrum 2xAAA: Not the brightest, but the beam is actually not a terrible CCT, and it feels AMAZING in the hands. Simple twist action. Made in USA, and VERY affordable. The beam focuses well to a hotspot with spill (MUCH better than my experience with larger Maglites). Probably a perfect gift for someone who wants something simple around the house. The maglite twisty action is still satisfying to use.
Convoy AAA: I like the CCT on these, and they're cheap, but they're clearly a cheap Chinese light, haha. So-so quality (very wobbly fit, endcap chews o-rings). Only maybe 50 lumens, so I LOVE giving these to kids. The Skilhunt E3A and Maglite Solitaire are much better for the price.
Almost great:
Maglite Solitare Spectrum: Everything you like about the solitaire, but with the efficiency of an LED and a CCT closer to the incandescent. Maybe the least awful beam of any Maglite? Made in USA, very affordable, rugged, and surprisingly lightweight. Still, it's a bit large. If you liked/loved a Solitaire at any point in the past, you NEED one of these, as it's probably going to be your new favorite.
GREAT LIGHTS:
Surefire Titan Plus: Despite having the ugliest beam I've ever seen in my life (It's more green than any light I own), this is an amazing EDC light. The stock titanium clip was a bit sharp, but stoning it fixed that up. I MUCH prefer the Prometheus clip. This light has been an EDC for...years, and it still looks new. It feels amazing in the hand, and has absolutely buttery threads. The UI is fantastic and reliable. The beam, despite the hideous tint and CCT, is amazing. The reflector on this is a thing of beauty (people poop on Surefire a lot online, but everyone else seems to mostly just use off-the-shelf reflectors, so this really gives Surefire an edge). I've charged the included Eneloop pro maybe twice or thrice, so using it on low, I have plenty of run time. Made in USA, and you can feel it. I've seen people whine about the price, but I got it for $100 before I really even got into flashlights, and it's been worth every penny...in fact, I think it's actually a pretty good bargain for the street prices you can find them on sale for.
Peak Eiger: I got these in single mode to skip dealing with the finnicky nature of QTC. These are so nice. With the Prometheus clip, it's an EDC dream. The ultra head is cool, but I like that the normal head means this slides into a shirt/pants "pen(cil) pocket" perfectly. Fantastic quality. Made in USA, and surprisingly affordable, considering the quality. From the site, warm is the ONLY high CRI option...and this made me fall in love with warm CCTs. Everyone should have one. You can get the SS Eiger shipped to your door for like under $80. The price/value curve on this thing is really high. If Robyn made a slick website and Instagram profile, she could probably sell these for a few hundred each. That's the other nice part; Robyn is very nice. Just be a bit patient, though, haha.
Killzone penlight: Cheap, pretty, simple. It's got a nice beam, too. This is kind of the ultimate desk light and/or present light. Know someone who could benefit from keeping a simple light on their desk? Get them this and an Eneloop AAA set with the charger for Christmas. It's not the best made light, but for the price, it's simple and elegant. Every time I use it, I'm shocked at how wonderful it is...for $15!?
Skilhunt E3A: Want the best EDC for a tight budget? This is it. Comes in cool, neutral, and warm (high CRI). It's shockingly bright, single mode twisty, and the floody TIR makes for a fanstastic beam that is just a single, even hotspot. They are lightweight, durable, and come in pretty colors. My other "go to gift" for non-flashlight people. Everyone loves them, and will spend YEARS telling you how much they use it and love it. I've converted people to caring about CRI from these, haha. The high CRI version is like $11. When Skilhunt codes aren't being broken and terrible, and I buy a light from them, I just fill my cart with these to get the maximum discounts, and then pass them out during the holiday season.