Just wondering who is a fan of the rosy color temp, like from the NTG50 emitters? Sometimes I think I like it,...but other times...not really. I have two Emisar with this emitter.
Who Is A Fan: Rosy
- Thread starter Orion
- Start date
jacobd
Enlightened
I love rosy emitters. I have an older HDS Rotary with an old D180 bin of SW45k and it's just magic.
Do you find them to be less "high CRI" than something like the XHP70? I have a 4K emitter in a DA1K that seems to have better CRI than the 4200K NTG50, because of the rosy output. I won't say one is necessarily "better" than the other. When I use it by itself, it seems like it has really good color transmission, but when I compare the two, I can tell the NTG50 is a bit less "CRI". It could just be the luck of the draw. But yeah, the rosy looks pretty.
Perhaps a year ago, I first purchased a Rosy tint flashlight.
First thing I did was shine it on a white wall,
and immediately thought: " EWWWW ! Too Magenta ! "
But then, I took it into my completely dark basement,
and actually *USED* it. And instantly Fell In Love with it !
Much, much better to be a bit Magenta (rosy),
than to be ANY trace of Green !
My opinion, anyway . . . .
YMMV
First thing I did was shine it on a white wall,
and immediately thought: " EWWWW ! Too Magenta ! "
But then, I took it into my completely dark basement,
and actually *USED* it. And instantly Fell In Love with it !
Much, much better to be a bit Magenta (rosy),
than to be ANY trace of Green !
My opinion, anyway . . . .
YMMV
Oh, for sure,....rosy is MUCH better than greenish. I've had some in my days. Bleh...
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2011
- Messages
- 7,443
- City & State/Province
- On the east coast of the yoosah. In the place wher
Without specifying the DUV, slight rosiness in warmish-neutral to neutral CCT is probably the sweet spot for me. Too cool of a CCT (4500<) and the rosiness is weird, neutral DUV is better. In the NTG50 line, I like the 4200k. For the Nichia 219b, I like 3500k-4500k. As for the 519A, I really like the neutrality of the stock domed LED in most of the CCT, but can appreciate the rosy shift after the dedome.
In the warmer CCT, I find a rosy shift to be slightly unsettling...It's hard to describe, but imagine a campfire that would normally be comforting and relaxing, but it's suddenly emitting an extra wavelength of light that's somehow keeping you awake/alert..
In the warmer CCT, I find a rosy shift to be slightly unsettling...It's hard to describe, but imagine a campfire that would normally be comforting and relaxing, but it's suddenly emitting an extra wavelength of light that's somehow keeping you awake/alert..
![Pampers Sensitive Baby Wipes, Clinically Proven, Fragrance Free, Unscented, Water Based, Hypoallergenic, Multi-Use, Hand Wipes 336 Wipes Total (6X Flip-Top Packs) [Packaging May Vary]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41KLBHu9CAL._SL500_.jpg)
AMD64Brunette
Enlightened
jon_slider
Flashaholic
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2015
- Messages
- 6,821
Team anti-green for me ;-)
I don't own a "rosy" flashlight (NTG, FFL emitters etc.), but from what I have seen of a wide array of beamshots, I do not like it.
I am very much Team Yellow, which should be a positive DUV-value, but limited from to around 1000K to sub-5000K (which is the CCT-range I like the most anyway). Above 5000K, if I am reading the charts right, the yellow becomes green. Intensity based on the value number..
...And looking at a chart like the one below, I can really tell how bad my monitors are at colour accuracy. >-<
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but are rosy tints a negative DUV value, but spans across the whole range of CCTs?
If so, I can see the appeal of rosy tints - it's like a "cheat" to get flashlights with cold tints (and with that, increased perceived brightness), but without the green tint.
If anything, I am definitely Team Anti-Green, aka photon vomit (Nitecore, I am looking at you)!
I am very much Team Yellow, which should be a positive DUV-value, but limited from to around 1000K to sub-5000K (which is the CCT-range I like the most anyway). Above 5000K, if I am reading the charts right, the yellow becomes green. Intensity based on the value number..
...And looking at a chart like the one below, I can really tell how bad my monitors are at colour accuracy. >-<
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but are rosy tints a negative DUV value, but spans across the whole range of CCTs?
If so, I can see the appeal of rosy tints - it's like a "cheat" to get flashlights with cold tints (and with that, increased perceived brightness), but without the green tint.
If anything, I am definitely Team Anti-Green, aka photon vomit (Nitecore, I am looking at you)!
Last edited:
As much as I think I won't like rosy tints, I can't and won't say for sure until I have tried one.
@jon_slider I really like the NTG50 2700K you show above - what can I expect (CCT / DUV) from a 2x NTG35 2700K + 2x 4200K mix? Looking at the D4V2.
@jon_slider I really like the NTG50 2700K you show above - what can I expect (CCT / DUV) from a 2x NTG35 2700K + 2x 4200K mix? Looking at the D4V2.
That is kind of what I was getting at in my second post. It seems like a yellow tone seems to give better color CRI over the rosy. I have both and that's how it seems to me. Both are nice, though.
I used the word "seems" too much in this post. At least, that's what it seems like to me. Seems about right.
Last edited:
+
Do I prefer rosy tints?
How many people buy a big roll of Roscolux (Rosco 304 Pale Apricot) tint filter?
that after trying nearly all in that range
It cancels out shorter wavelengths to make anything a great neutral or warm tint that's slightly rosy.
Have it in several lights and it's not overly aggressive.
I cannot do yellowy tints, just can't do it.
Bought it around 10years ago, man how time flies.
btw:
LHP531 and LHP73B emitters in 4000K may be the best stock tint I'v ever seem
Do I prefer rosy tints?
How many people buy a big roll of Roscolux (Rosco 304 Pale Apricot) tint filter?
that after trying nearly all in that range
It cancels out shorter wavelengths to make anything a great neutral or warm tint that's slightly rosy.
Have it in several lights and it's not overly aggressive.
I cannot do yellowy tints, just can't do it.
Bought it around 10years ago, man how time flies.
btw:
LHP531 and LHP73B emitters in 4000K may be the best stock tint I'v ever seem
jon_slider
Flashaholic
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2015
- Messages
- 6,821
Negative DUV at 5000k is more rosy than at 2700k, which is more orange
Jean-Luc Descarte
Flashlight Enthusiast
Yes. I can take neutral or negative duv, but I'm firmly on Team Anti-Green. Every light of mine with a positive duv has been gifted away or sold.
My rosiest light is a Convoy S21B with a dedomed 519A 4000K, that I operated on because the original domed emitter was kinda on the positive duv side and I didn't enjoy it. Now it looks like a 3500K but, well, more rosy, without looking unnatural or compromising the CRI as far as my eyesight can tell.
Before that, I've owned a Convoy S2 (non +) with an XM-L2 slightly below the BBL and a Thrunite Ti3 "neutral white" with an XP-G2 about as rosy as the S21B I talked about. They have nice tints to look at but that's it.
All of my other lights have duv pretty much at the BBL or only slightly below it. Including an S2+ with a B35AM 6500K that's if anything more like 7000K — that thing is blue.
Sure helps that I refuse to use any lenses with purple AR coating. It's either green AR coating or no coating at all.
My rosiest light is a Convoy S21B with a dedomed 519A 4000K, that I operated on because the original domed emitter was kinda on the positive duv side and I didn't enjoy it. Now it looks like a 3500K but, well, more rosy, without looking unnatural or compromising the CRI as far as my eyesight can tell.
Before that, I've owned a Convoy S2 (non +) with an XM-L2 slightly below the BBL and a Thrunite Ti3 "neutral white" with an XP-G2 about as rosy as the S21B I talked about. They have nice tints to look at but that's it.
All of my other lights have duv pretty much at the BBL or only slightly below it. Including an S2+ with a B35AM 6500K that's if anything more like 7000K — that thing is blue.
Sure helps that I refuse to use any lenses with purple AR coating. It's either green AR coating or no coating at all.
