I have one of those 3C Defiant Super throwers, with the big deep reflector, running an XML emitter.
I'm wondering... can I just swap out the XML emitter with a XHP35 or XHP50 and run it direct drive on 3* 18500 cells?
If so... what would be the advantage of one XHP over the other?
Yes and no.
Can you convert it? Yes. It is actually a very good host. Large heatsink, it has multiple joints which afford access to all the components, heatsink, reflector, lens, driver, switch etc. The large, deep reflector also throws well.
Can you direct drive any of the above mentioned LEDs? No. XHP35 is a 12v emitter. XHP50 and XHP70 are available in 6V and 12V configurations, none of which will work DD with 3 cells. The 6V emitters would instaflash, and the 12V versions would have to high of a Vf to work DD. What you can do is run 2 26650 and use an appropriate driver.
The XHP70 will have the highest output, widest hotspot, and most likely have a crossed shadow in the center of the beam. It bothers some people, others have said it's not too noticeable. I haven't run run with that reflector so I can't say how noticeable it would be. An XHP50 would be in the middle of the 3 as far as output, as well as hotspot size. The XHP35 would have the tightest hotspot, and the least bright comparatively. Still close to 2000 lumens run at stock configuration, so not dim, just not as bright as the other two. I'd go with the XHP35 if it were me, second choice would be the XHP50.
-Michael