While I do follow a motto of live and let live, ie, anyone can love whatever movie they like, I won't critisize because there are rediculously bad movies that I love to death too, anyway this is my personal take on it.
I thought the movie was terrible, I saw it with a friend in his home and afterwoods I had said it was "pretty good", but that was being modest.
The costumes are rediculously and laughably bad, except for the girls costume, that is the only redeeming feature.
The nose of the main character's costume really pisses me off actually, its like a yellow rectangle on his noze, combined with a green suit!? wtf?
It reminds me of a line of sports underwear.
The acting was sloppy to say the least and didn't convey any sort of "Kick assingness" at all, its about the same quality as I would expect from a well done Youtube clip.
To me the epitome of great superhero films though is Batman (1989), and before anyone compares that movie with Kick-*** based upon the same techniques of kicking-***, the main character did use a taser and the girl used a sword, Batman uses considerable amounts of technology inorder to get what he wants.
But the whole point of a costume is to convey fear and respect, a man's clothes reflect who he is, in Kick-*** the clothes do not reflect this, infact all they do is tell me that this movie has had very little preperation and forethought on the matter, it for me made the movie feel like a knock-together Youtube video done by amateurs, not a proper movie, that right there instantly ticked me off, if I'm going to PAY money for a movie I want quality, I don't want cheap costumes and a cheap experience., the actors costumes cheapen the experience considerably.
To top it off, the main big dad character (that looks like Batman) is a BLATANT ripoff of Batman, whats going through my mind at this time is "why the hell am I watching this when I could be watching a REAL Batman movie?", in return for watching this festivity of terribleness I am exposed to shitty acting that reminds me of some geek walking around doing fake wrestling and doing some spring cleaning in his office or home, not "kicking-***" and doing superhero type things, it barely has any sort of originality and the originality that it DOES have is something that doesn't interest me at all.
So I got bored with it, really really bored. Then annoyed. Then angry that such a movie with such potential was given such crappy acting and B movie costumes.
Ontop of that again, the guy in the black cape with red striping is SO FRIGGEN ANNOYING! and WHINEY!
And yes I agree with the OP, its got too much violence to be a kids movie, but its got such terrible acting that it is on the same level as a kids movie, its a failure in both markets. The only market where its a good fit is the ghetto 12-16 year old crowd and thats what makes it so popular, you wouldn't see this playing in some rich guy's apartment amongst his family and friends, or on Grandma's television set.
It doesn't teach your kids how to be a better person, it doesn't teach them anything aside from how to be angry and voilent and it also lets them vent their frustrations inside of their mind instead of in public, kind of like Doom + Metallica marathons for me back in the 1990s. Which is a good thing depending upon how you take it.
It is a diffuser for violence and frustration among teens, so instead of combatting and tackling society's issues and putting that anger and violence where its better suited, its diffused into this movie.
And people think this isn't just another Hollywood movie? its doing the exact same thing as every other hollywood movie does, cheap thrills, cheap violence, terrible acting, terrible costumes, and going only after one thing, your money.
The only thing that it does DIFFERENTLY to /ANY OTHER MOVIE/ is its using pre-teen and under legal age sex appeal to rake them in instead of the usual tricks.