Last nights battle royal was so large it was just round 1.
The idea was to take fairly current double a and triple a lights in the field and spot a football 5 paces into a dense under brush laden wood line. The football had dingey white stripes.
It was a cold (read lots of pockets), moonlit night not far from a shopping mall with all of its free lumens. I did manage to find a dark area below the elevation of the influence of the light pollution.
The thinking was the ability to spot a perp dressed in dark clothing lying on the ground just inside the woods. The distance was 50', 50 yards and 100 yards.
The players were the Streamlight 1L on a double a (135 lumens) , a stylus pro (54? lumens), a protac 1aaa (70 lumens), a wooden light by Menards (80 lumens), a 300 lumen Rayovac indestructable, a 178 lumen Pelican 2320 (gen 2), Icon Rogue 1&2 (50/100 lumens), the Modus 1&2 (72 and 100? lumens), and the polished alluminum Energizer 1 and 2 double a's (77&125 lumens).
To guide the way the Rayovac using it's 60 lumen low showed me that thing aint no joke. By the time I got to the woods a few others on low had been tried and I liked the Pelican choice better than all the others, but kept using the Rayovac simply because it was so impressive on the 60 lumen setting.
I reached the woods and saw a football laying near the edge of the field next to them. Viola! Find the perp mode.
At 100 yards every light was eliminated except the Rayovac, the Pelican and the 2aa Energizer.
The Rayovac stole the show. But the Pelican was no slouch at only 178 lumens. The Energizer at 177 also did a great job. It threw as far as the Rayovac but total area lit was a lot less.
For kicks n giggles I pulled out the PR-1 with a PRX thrower head on it and holy cow! I think I heard the tress shout "turn out that dam light!" lol.
So then 50 yards was tried and a bunch of others got the job done. Surprisingly the Stylus pro won that one. But the Icons, the 1aa Energizer and ProTac 1L were plenty bright. The Rogue 1 and 1aaa ProTac were the laggers in the grand scheme of things.
(The big surprise was how much more area is lit and farther throw of the Pelican vs the ProTac 1L, it wasn't even close)
At 50' each one easily lit the football. For that one I also used the Rayovac and Pelican on low. The Pelican low setting didn't quite do it.
I failed to mentions the Menards wooden light but overall it lit the football at 50 yards with it's pencil beam but really impressed at 50' as the gentle spill lit a wider area than all the rest.
Basically another a fuel battle royal will take place. This time with a couple of mini mags, a 2 for $10 Defiant, a Coast HP1 and the winners of last night (Pelican, Rayovac and Stylus pro).