Take a look at lithium mines for your electric cars. The notion of replacing oil with anything in the forseeable future is laughable and you know it.
The
plausible argument I see is to replace ICEs with EVs
where the use cases make sense. I - and a large slice of the residents of my region with access to private parking - could replace my daily driver with an EV that has a nominal range of around 200 miles charging exclusively at home. My parents that live in rural AR perhaps less so since a trip "to town" for errands can get uncomfortably close to that range and unless you're making a relatively linear trip on certain interstate corridors in a vehicle whose maker starts with "T", public charging is still kinda iffy.
While there are surely humorless zealots out there that will insist that whatever a certain billionaire drew up on the back of a figurative napkin will suffice for everyone, they are not to be taken seriously since their arguments are clearly flawed.
It is nice to see someone bring up the other dirty side of the lithium equation. It is never discussed much but should be.
This is actually discussed all the time - it's just not the huge concern it's often made out to be. With ~
~160g of elemental lithium per kWh (first response) of practical battery pack that's an entire 16kg of Li for a huge 100kWh pack that's apt to last for a decade or more with the potential to either recover the lithium afterwards or repurpose the modules for years of additional service. In exchange, you need not
directly burn literal tons of fuel at millions of distributed points over the lifetime of owning an ICE-powered vehicle
(200,000 miles / 40 MPG = 5000 gallons of fuel at ~6 lb/gallon = 30,000 pounds or or 15 tons).
But with all the hand-wringing over lithium
(or that other modern favorite, Cobalt) no one talks about the orders of magnitude more aluminum, steel, copper, rubber, plastic - themselves all damaging to the environment to extract, produce, and dispose of - that goes into
all new vehicle production.
EV's aren't made of and powered by the laughter of children and unicorn farts for sure - but neither is anything else made in an industrial society.
Reduction is the name of the game, not wholly impossible
elimination.