zespectre
Flashlight Enthusiast
Typically I'd be right there with you, I'm not especially fond of battery carriers either.One thing that I find to be a turnoff about the D40A vs the EA4 is the fact that it uses a battery carrier.
However I do have to say that in use this one is not bad at all. Solidly built and the sides are open enough that the batteries are actually easy to tap out when the carrier is out. I also like the fact that while battery alignment matters, it doesn't matter which way you put the carrier back into the light.
An issue I've had recently is super-tight battery compartments where some AA rechargeable -barely- fit, especially after I've put my tracking label on the side of the batteries. Obviously this is not a problem with the D40A.