In rotary , I'm drawn to the raised switch for its ease of operation and relatively high resistance to wear. However, do you think features like tail-standing capability, a low-profile design, and resistance to accidental activation in the pocket offer an irreplaceable advantage for pocket carry?
In reagrds to your questions. IMO, it's pretty much comes down to what's important, or how you plan on using the light.
For example re. how I carrry, and use my Rotary's. I belt carry my Rotary's in a Kydex Holster. I have both the raised, and flush button configurations. While working (or when I worked), I carried the reaised button. My preference for the raised button, is for the ease of turning the light on using the side/flat part of my thumb.
I carry the flush button when I EDC the light, of which, I have to use the tip/end part of my thumb to turn the light on. Since I carry the flush button most often, I have a back up "Rotary control 123 battery compartment with flush button" on hand.
Aside from user er, err, ... error. ... :) My Rotary's hasn't accidentally turned on. However, if you're concerned about the light turning on in your pocket (which would concern me as well if I caried a light in this manner).
There are two ways you could lock out the button. Check out the following link to
"EDC Rotary Flashlihgt Advanced User Guide". See no. 6
"Disabling the Switch" in the guide.
HDS Systems Advance User Guide
This is a vid by HDS Systems: How to enable the auto turn off function in you HDS EDC Flashlight:
Side note: plug in
"HDS Rotary", or
"HDS Systems" in YouTube's search bar, and a seclection of User Programing Guides with show up. .. (y)
Hope this helps. ... (y) (y)