Enderman
Enlightened
Re: 1?? Mcd Xenon Flashlight Project - BFF
HID is just a middle ground in between all of them, it doesn't win at any one thing.
Well, LEDs can do more than 115lm/W, and they can do more than 10,000 lumens, and short arc and LEP can do more throw.I beg to differ on your over generalization of the performance of high Powered well focused HiD at say 70 to 85 watts getting more than 115 lumens per watt, still better than high Powered LED efficacy. That's 8000 to 10,000 well focused lumens and more practical for real life use than short arc which can be focused even more tightly.
HID is just a middle ground in between all of them, it doesn't win at any one thing.