Car travel doesn't agree with me. I get nauseous in short order due to the fumes and outgassing from car interiors. Besides that, I don't want to be bothered having to operate a vehicle. Too much legal responsibility if something goes wrong.
Fumes and outgassing on car interiors? Do you have any idea what goes into mass transit vehicles, especially in terms of flame-retardant chemicals? For that matter, the rubber flooring used in most US mass transit vehicles stinks to high heaven.
The subway fare is capped at $35 a week if you use OMNI no matter how many trips you take. If you do a normal 5-day work week you pay $30 per week. That's less than car insurance alone in NYC.
That's one of a couple hundred reasons why I don't live in NYC. Taxes alone ensured I never "worked" in NYC even when I was.
It's quicker to take the subway than car for many trips. I'm in Manhattan in 30 to 40 minutes using the Q64 bus and the Queens Boulevard express. Driving takes longer except during early AM hours.
The Black Cars they had for us were quite efficient. I took the subway from time to time. But stopped going to NYC entirely after 2015.
Your calculations presuppose you have the money to trade for time. A person making $15 an hour certainly can't afford a car. I couldn't afford one even when I was making $100K, not that I wanted one anyway. Also time on a train isn't wasted time. You can study or do some work. Can't do that while driving. A 2 hour car trip is time down the drain.
Plenty of people making $15/hr afford cars here. The vast majority of them, actually. Reminder: There's no income tax here. That's 7-15% tax savings over what NY State+NYC squander from your paycheck there, not to mentioned the inflated prices of NYC. You can get waterfront condos here for $200k. Non-waterfront for $110k (asking).
Study or working on the subway? Doubtful. Amtrak? Definitely possible, and yes, in many cases would be a better work zone than in a car.
A 2 hour car trip is hardly a waste of time. I even typed out a 30 page term paper on a 2.5 hr drive, on a Blackberry, touch-typing the entre time. Highest grade in the class, graduate level microbiology class FWIW. And that's old-school tech there. With my current cars, I'm usually working the whole time. Everything from airline reorganisations to corporate mergers to law enforcement raids have been orchestrated in my car while driving. If anything, all of those things I just mentioned there could
not have been done in public transit due to confidentiality and security requirements.
There's the crux of your argument. You don't travel, so you have no need for a vehicle.
For some of us, travel isn't a luxury or an escape — it's simply life. I've been on-call 24/7 since I was 14, and since 16, my car has never left the driveway without a fully packed suitcase in the trunk, alongside my mobile office bag and emergency bag. I'm more at home in a Marriott than in my own house, and I have more friends — and more memberships — in cities I don't live in than in the one I do. It's also why I do General Aviation, to be able to get places rapidly, with an unpredictable schedule.
A few years back I walked into the office on a Wednesday after having just gotten back from the West coast that night/morning. "What are you doing this weekend?" "I'm not sure, unpacking, getting reorganised, etcetera." "Well, in that case, head home and get all of that crap done. You're going to Alaska on Saturday." No warning this was coming down the pipeline. No idea of duration either. It could have been 12 hours, or 12 months, I wouldn't know until I was on-site for a week at the client's headquarters. Even that week was crazy, traveling around Alaska and back-and-forth to Seattle. I truly had no idea where I'd be sleeping each night for the first two weeks of the engagement.